RSS

A difference between Lamb To The Slaughter and The Way Up To Heaven.

20 Feb

Though both of the stories is about Lying and deception, there is still a slight difference between the two stories.

Similarities:
1. In both short stories, there is a similar theme, which is lying and deception.
2.Both main characters are Mary Maloney and Mrs Foster in Lam To The Slaughter and The Way Up To Heaven respectively.
3.The wives in the story were very caring and over-pleasing. However, their husbands do not treat them well .
4.Both the main characters planned out the murder successfully.
5.Both were free from murder in the end.
6.Both are shrewd and smart to create an alibi.

Difference:

Lamb To The Slaughter:

Mrs Maloney is a devoted wife to Mr Maloney . She has a strong sense of security when she was with her husband. She could not live without him.

Mrs Maloney was finally pregnant, with six months already. However, her husband told her that he was going to leave her.

Mrs Maloney chose not to face up to reality. However, Mrs Maloney could not accept the fact that her husband was going to leave her. So, she planned out the murder.

Her husband said that he would be going out alone for dinner instead of having it together like they always do on Thursday. Mrs Maloney then revealed her dark side. From a caring and meticulous wife to a cruel and evil murderer.

She was about to prepare a lamb chop for her husband when he said he was going out. She had already taken the lamb out from the freezer. Then, she just hit her husband’s head with that piece of lamb without knowing.

She was just all of a sudden knocked out from her senses and she was scared-stiff. She did not know what to do. She quickly changed herself and tried to put up a smile though it came out very perculiar.

She managed to calm down and off she went to the grocer to buy some ingredients for the lamb chop she had planned out. Her alibi was that a housewife went buying groceries and was shock to see her husband lying dead on the floor. Then she would call the police that she saw what happened in the end and remained innocent. As a detective’s wife, she certainly knew the consequences of murder.

Then her husband’s colleagues arrived and what was most surprisingly was not her acting on being depressed, it was how she actually disposed the murder weapon. She cooked the lamb and gave the colleagues to eat for their hard work. There was no way they could find out the murder weapon then……

The Way Up To Heaven:

Mrs Foster had a dread of being late. This has grown into almost an obsession and irritates Mr Foster. Yet, he enjoys keeping his wife waiting for him.

One January morning, Mr and Mrs Foster were preparing to leave for France to visit their daughter and grandchildren. Mr Foster again was keeping her wife waiting

The weather that day was very foggy and the flight had been postponed. Mrs Foster decided to wait and was told that the next flight was on eleven the following  morning.

Mrs Foster telephoned home and realised that her husband had yet left for his club and he insist that he would stay with her so that she  could drop him by the club on the way to the airport. She decides to return home and set off next morning.

Next morning, Mrs Foster was ready to leave at eight-thirty. Once again, Mr Foster kept her waiting again. When they got into the car, he claims that he had forgotten about the present for his daughter and he returns home to find it.

It was almost late and Mrs Foster would definitely missed her flight. Then she found out that the present was actually tucked under the side of the car seat. She then went to her apartment and listen for some sound and not entering her apartment.

Then she sprang back to life and hurried the chauffeur to the airport as she was going to miss the flight. She told the chauffeur that her husband would take a cab to the club by himself. She managed to board the plane with a few minutes to spare and she was on the plane on the reclining chair. She knew that her husband was trapped in the lift.

She finally reached Paris and she spent there for six weeks. After which, she returns from her wonderful trip. She seems more clam than before. Then, she saw alot of mails behind the door and noticed a strange smell. She walks around the hall confirming or investigating something. She then calls the repairman to repair the lift immediately and waited patiently for the arrival of the repair man……

Advertisements
 
2 Comments

Posted by on February 20, 2010 in Uncategorized

 

2 responses to “A difference between Lamb To The Slaughter and The Way Up To Heaven.

  1. Bram

    February 21, 2010 at 8:40 am

    Yes, I agree with what you wrote, except for the part where you wrote, “Both the main characters planned out the murder successfully.” I don’t think Mary Maloney planned the murder of her husband at all. She simply murdered him out of a sudden fit of anger.

     
  2. Jack Tan (07)

    February 26, 2010 at 1:49 pm

    This is nicely summarised and makes a lot of sense. I agree that Mrs Foster knew that his husband was trapped in the lift and wanted him to die. Mary Maloney was certainly knocked out of her senses when she killed her husband. Just an opinion I have and thought I want to share with you

    Jack(07) 1O3

     

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

 
%d bloggers like this: